A deconstruction of perceived value in the music of Katy Perry
Tuesday, November 25th, 2008In a book I recently read, I came across a very interesting quote. It said that “every attempt to persuade people that something is good (or bad) in itself, and not merely in its effects, depends upon the art of rousing feelings, not upon an appeal to evidence.”
Because I understand that mentioning a moment of fear I experienced when I was sure I was wearing nothing flame retardant to inhibit the fiery mess I’d make if I happened to explode from rage when I witnessed four men bouncing and lip syncing to “Hot and Cold” will do little to bring about sympathy, I will attempt to persuade you all that Katy Perry is bad by employing a strategy that will both rouse emotions and appeal to evidence.
Point 1: Katy Perry offers nothing unique to the musical world.
A relatively rational individual who has listened to Ms. Perry’s music for any length of time will come upon two conclusions: the songs are catchy as genital herpes and the lyrics bring to mind a dump truck full of stale mixed metaphors covered in smelly cliches. Her big hit songs include such lyrical gems as “I kissed a girl, and I liked it”, “you’re so gay and you don’t even like boys”, and the entirety of the chorus for “Hot and Cold”. Hooray, Katy! You kissed a girl like so many drunk chicks before you in an attempt to explore your sexuality and test the limits of your relationship! How we laud you and your open-mindedness! News flash: I don’t fucking care, and that’s mostly because that song was done 13 years ago way more impressively by someone more talented than you times infinity. And how can a guy be gay if he doesn’t like boys? I know you’re not aware of the more old-fashioned usage of the word, so are you using “gay” as an insult? How urbane. And could you please be more creative than “hot and cold”, “yes and no”, “up and down”? I know your manager probably informed you that your core audience would be 15 year-old girls and boys of varying levels of intelligence, but I doubt he said “your songs can only be as smart as your dumbest fan.”
Point 2: There is nothing extraordinary about her music.
I think it would be safe to say that her two biggest draws are her infectiously catchy melodies and the shock value of “going there”. Her songs are frequently stuck in my head, I’ll give her that. I’d also give her a kick to the tits if I had the chance for believing for even a New York minute that she’s unique and groundbreaking in any way. Oh, my! She’s not even bothering to mask her messages with symbolism or allusions! What will we do with this bare-bones barrage? Um, we could always take the lack of extra effort to conceal for what it is: an inability to craft thoughtful phrases due to a weak literary imagination. It’s so tired to be bold these days. We’ve had blatant and wild since the ’60′s back when it really was shocking, so if you want to be someone today you’ve really gotta bring it. Does she bring it? No. I’d rather have to research the meanings of lyrics to get the full understanding than begin the process of wading out into the wordy waters only to realize I’m standing in a puddle. I’ve been sensing a downward spiral in popular music in the past few years, and in the same way I doubt humans today are the pinnacle of evolution, I also doubt Katy Perry will mark the end of pop’s devolution. That frightens me deeply.
Point 3: I have too much in common with Katy Perry to not hate her.
Katy Perry is female. I am female. Instant connection. I have no desire to transition in order to escape this gender commonality with her, but nor would I three-move check-mate the males of this world into death by shame by coercing her to have a gender identity epiphany and transition herself. I also wouldn’t dare to slide her over into the androgynous category as mentioned by Aristophanes since I consider the modern application of androgyny to be quite attractive. Unfortunately, the only solution might be to make Katy Perry a former member of the human race. She’s a blight on humanity and we must act swiftly and without mercy. Immediate excommunication.
I have more points, but I grow weary of reining in my fury in order to present hard-hitting facts to further discredit this musical scam artist. If there is anybody brave enough to rebut me, please bring it on. I do so love a debate, and I feel confident that I could verbally decapitate an opponent in this battle. In the same way that we cannot help with whom we fall in love, we likewise cannot help what we find to be an auditory pleasure. So long as the affection for Ms. Perry and her stupid-ass songs is only skin-deep, I am confident I can remain friends with anyone who does not 100% agree with me on this.